Skip to content
10% OFF code "MONPORT"
Subscribe to active 5% OFF "MONPORT"
Diode Laser VS CO2 Laser - Why CO2 laser engraver is more popular?

Diode Laser VS CO2 Laser - Why CO2 laser engraver is more popular?

 

 Ⅰ.How much do you know about lasers?

Diodes, CO2 - all these lasers engravers are available on the market, but do you know which laser is right for you or can meet your needs? 

Which one is suitable for the material that I have? Which machine have better effect and high efficiency? 

Hopefully, this article will help you decide or learn about diode laser and CO2 lasers and its engravers. 

Laser Types 

The laser light source is the core component of laser engraving machine. The characteristics of the light source determine the material effect of the laser machine to achieve engraving, and the energy level has a significant impact on the depth and speed of the engraving. Thus, let me introduce you the different types of lasers and their light-emitting principles, so that you can have a deeper understanding of diode laser engraving machines and CO2 laser engraving machines. 

The different laser types use different components and generate a light beam at different wavelengths – these wavelengths are suited to different types of materials that they can engrave upon. 

All lasers can be divided into the following categories according to the state of the working material: Solid-state lasers (crystal and glass), Gas lasers, Liquid lasers, Semiconductor lasers,Free electron laser. 

Gas lasers, the working material they use is gas, and according to the nature of the working particles that actually produce stimulated emission in the gas, they are further divided into atomic gas Lasers, ion gas lasers, molecular gas lasers, excimer gas lasers, etc.; CO2 laser belongs to this type. 

Semiconductor lasers, this type of laser uses a certain semiconductor material as a working substance to generate excitation The principle of emission is achieved by exciting non-equilibrium carriers between the energy bands of semiconductor materials or between energy bands and impurity levels through a certain excitation method (electric injection, optical pump or high-energy electron beam injection) The population is inverted to produce stimulated emission of light; 

  • Diode Lasers: 

Diode lasers

The core component of a diode laser is a semiconductor diode. More specifically, this is a p-n junction diode made of a p-type and an n-type semiconductor. The p-n junction is like a revolving door, allowing electrons to flow through the potential barrier. 

Laser diodes usually use semiconductors made of aluminum or gallium arsenide alloy. Current is supplied through the diode, which induces electrons to flow through the p-n junction. These electrons combine with holes on the other side of the junction, releasing excess energy in the form of photons. 

The gap between the two semiconductors acts as a "mirror" that amplifies the intensity of photons. Photons bounce back and forth through this gap and collide with other incoming electronic devices. This "resonance" helps produce more photons. It takes hundreds of collisions to obtain the required optical gain in a diode laser. 

In more complex applications, several semiconductor diodes can be stacked together. Multiple beams from these diodes can be focused into a single beam, thereby making the output more powerful. This also makes it possible to create multiple lasers with different wavelength values. 

  • CO2 Lasers: 

CO2 detailed image

The wavelength of CO2 laser is about 10.6 μm (infrared), an important industrial laser. 

The CO2 laser is a gas laser with CO2 gas as the working substance. The discharge tube is usually made of glass or quartz material, and it is filled with CO2 gas and other auxiliary gases (mainly helium and nitrogen, and usually a small amount of hydrogen or xenon); the electrode is generally a hollow cylinder made of nickel; resonant cavity One end is a gold-plated total reflection mirror, and the other end is a partial reflection mirror polished with germanium or gallium arsenide. When a high voltage (usually DC or low-frequency AC) is applied to the electrode, a glow discharge is generated in the discharge tube, and there is a laser output at one end of the germanium mirror, and its wavelength is in the mid-infrared band near 10.6 microns; generally a better tube . A discharge area of about one meter long can obtain a continuous output power of 40 to 60 watts. CO2 laser is a relatively important gas laser.

. Diode laser engraver VS CO2 laser engraver  

 

Pros

Cons

Diode laser engraver

  • Portable and low weight
  • Cost saving
  • Wide spectrum of wavelength
  • Fixed-focus
  • Less powerful
  • Limited applications

 

CO2 laser engraver

  • More powerful
  • Fast & high accuracy 
  • Large working area
  • Available for various materials
  • Bigger size and heavy
  • Fragile construction
  • More expensive

 

 

Next, We will make a comparison between diode laser engraver and CO2 laser engraver from the following main aspects:

  • Power

No single diode can create more than 10 watt optical power. Cutting paper or balsa wood or engraving on leather is not a problem, but using metal or thicker wood may be impractical. If you are dealing with more challenging materials, CO2 laser engraver would be a better choice. 

One big advantage of CO2 lasers is that they usually have a large raw laser power. The smallest tube you can find on the market is at least 25 watts, and most CO2 machines have a power output of 40-80 watts. The power of professional and industrial units is mostly up to 150 watts. Industrial units can reach 400 watts. The CO2 laser engraver can cut wood, acrylic, glass and certain metals. 

  • Speed and accuracy 

With higher power output, CO2 lasers engraver can also cut or engrave materials faster. This is valuable in an industrial environment where productivity and rapid turnover are key performance indicators. Therefore, CO2 lasers engraver are often seen in industrial manufacturing facilities. 

CO2 laser system marks wood, paper, plastics, leather, fabric, stone, and a wide range of other nonmetallic materials at up to 19.68 inches per second (500 mm/s) with pinpoint accuracy; everything works with most third-party graphic software, easily receiving files via internet or USB; and locking caster wheels allow you to easily move and secure your laser cutter whenever needed. Diode laser engraver is not as fast as CO2 laser engraver.

  • Size and weight

Diode laser engraver has a robust and easy-to-install structure design: The all-aluminum alloy anodized structure design makes the machine more durable and improves the accuracy of engraving. The entire structure adopts a rapid assembly design, and the assembly can generally be completed within 10-20 minutes. 

However, the CO2 laser machine is very large and heavy. The CO2 tube requires a lot of space. When we deal with industrial machines, size is not important, but once we talk about garages, workshops or small shops, it matters. Most small entrepreneurs or hobbyists simply don't have enough space for bulky equipment. 

  • Cost 

Generally, the cost of a diode laser engraver is only a few hundred of dollars, while the cost of a CO2 laser engraving machine is as high as thousands of dollars. Diode laser engraving does not entail additional costs, as it does not produce waste and does not need unique treatments or maintenance. 

Due to the requirement for high-precision engineering, CO2 laser engravers are generally more expensive than diode laser engravers. This is another important reason why CO2 laser engraving machine are not usually used in hobbyist applications or small manufacturing companies.

  •  Applications

Using a diode laser means simply accepting that you cannot engrave or cut many materials. The diode laser does not have enough power to engrave metal or glass unless some coating is applied to them. Diode lasers are also difficult to handle any shiny, transparent, translucent or completely white painted surface. 

But CO2 laser engravers are available for various materials. Works with Wood, Rubber, Plastic, Paper, Glass, Leather, Ceramics, Tile, Fabric, Cloth, Fiberglass, Marble, Cork, Jade, Acrylic, Veneer, Corian, Mylar, Delrin, Melamine, Pressboard, Cardboard, and more Non-Metal Materials. 

CO2 lasers are considered more suitable for heavy-duty applications. CO2 lasers are quite common in industrial environments, especially for cutting wood and glass.

  • Spectrum of wavelength

The diode laser has a wide spectrum of wavelength ranging from 405 to 1080 nm, however CO2 laser engraving machine only has a limited wavelength 10.6 uM (10600 nm) ( not work for metal engraving). 

  • Construction

The diode laser engraver no need to adjust the focus before engraving. With fixed focus lens and sliding design, you only need to slide the laser and tighten the screw to complete fast focusing of the laser engraver machine. The X and Y-axis contain precise scale lines, which is convenient for you to measure the size of engraving objects. 

In addition to being bulky, the CO2 laser is also very fragile because it is equipped with very tiny and intricately positioned mirrors. These mirrors must not be removed from alignment, lest the laser stop functioning as intended. Due to these characteristics, moving the CO2 laser frequently is not considered a good practice. 

  • Working area 

CO2 laser engraver is suitable for homes and businesses: including our 80-watt laser tube and our largest cutting surface, measuring 24 inches x 36 inches-nearly 6 square feet of work area, suitable for your large projects! The adjustable lifting engraving table has dual-channel doors, which can accommodate oversized and irregularly shaped objects.  

While the working area of diode laser engraver is smaller than CO2 laser engraver generally. You can also use diode lasers for small laser engraving business, like leather or paper products.

. Which one is right for you?

Choosing between the two is a simple matter. Diode laser engravers are cheaper, smaller, more durable and easier to use. This makes diode laser engravers more practical in daily use, or if you just want to use laser engraving as a hobby. You can also use diode lasers for small laser engraving business, like leather or paper products. 

CO2 laser engraving machines are more suitable for professional applications. Owning and operating a CO2 laser engraver can become very expensive, so if there is an opportunity to make a profit or use it for research, it should indeed be done. CO2 laser engravers are very picky, fragile, take up more working space, and require a fairly high level of operating skills. Because of the power level you need, using one also requires stricter safety measures. In general, it’s obvious that if you have limited working space and do not need to cut 24/7, you also do not need to cut very thick materials such as 10 mm plywood or wood etc , Then the diode laser is the best choice.

For some users, CO2 lasers engravers are still very versatile-because they have higher power, they can run faster and produce results quickly. If you want to carry out small-scale production or industrial production, this machine may be right for you.

If you buy a CO2 laser engraving machine because of its function, then the CO2 laser engraver is a worthwhile investment. On the other hand, diode lasers are more suitable for DIY hobby projects.

Finally, do you know which one is right for you? If you still have questions about different types of  laser engraving machine, or want to know more about any of our products, please contact us-we are very happy to help you meet all your engraving needs!

Previous article What can you do with a CO2 laser machine?
Next article Get Started with a CO2 laser machine

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare